Tips for Hosting Thanksgiving Dinner

Tips for Hosting Thanksgiving | The Silver Pen

Tips for Hosting Thanksgiving | The Silver PenDinner parties have a tendency to give me the heebie-jeebies, no matter how few people we have or how many. Now the Silver Lining of this angst is that this is  definitely a first world problem.  I mean, really.  Sometimes when I get myself all worked up, I tell myself to look in the mirror and remind myself that I’m not bald from chemo. This always gives me a great deal of perspective.

Every year we have between 3 and 10 people to our home for Thanksgiving.  Why? Well because I love nothing more than having people over and Thanksgiving happens to be one of my absolute favorite holidays. I have a tendency to be more relaxed when hosting Thanksgiving; however, I do have a few nerve bugs that rear their head.  Recently, I found Shauna Niequist’s blog and the absolute perfect post about hosting Thanksgiving.

Hope you enjoy Shauna’s tips as much as I am!  I happen to think that most of her tips (below) apply to a dinner party in general.

Ten Thoughts for Hosting Thanksgiving

  1. Remember: it’s about the gathering, not about the food. This is the most important thing to keep in mind. I know Thanksgiving might be the most food-driven of all holidays, but the people are always more important than the food. The gathering is what’s significant…that’s what you remind yourself when the turkey’s taking forever or the stuffing’s dry. And it’s TRUE.
  2. Stay classic. This is not the holiday to flout tradition. People become quite cranky if you don’t have, say, cranberry sauce or French fried onions on top of the green bean casserole. This is not the time to surprise people with a wild South-of-the-Border feast, or a beautiful spread of sushi. I have made this mistake, and people were not happy.
  3. Ask for help. No one, and I repeat, no one, should cook a Thanksgiving meal alone. Ask each guest to bring something, and invite a few people over to help set the table, prep veggies, etc. It’s always more fun together, and people like to be included in the process. Feel free to be specific about what to bring, and give people clear tasks when they ask how they can help.
  4. Invite people into meaningful conversation. If you’re not intentional, a whole day with family and friends can go by without a focused moment or conversation. It’s especially easy to let it pass because you’re stressed about all the food prep. Plan ahead–a question on the back of every placecard, or conversation cards scattered on the table. If you’re hosting, take the opportunity to invite deeper connection around your table. Feel free to be quite directive about it–it feels awkward in the moment, sometimes, but I find that people are always thankful afterward. People want to connect deeply, but it often takes one person to create an environment that allows it.
  5. Simple table idea: cover table with butcher paper or kraft paper, and then decorate it with words and pictures–and if kids can do this, all the better. Set jars filled with colored pencils all over the table, so that people can doodle and add to the decorations. Sometimes people get really stressed out at big holidays, feeling like they have to have some spectacular tablescape–cornucopias! Gourds! A woodland village! If that’s your jam, go for it, definitely. But if that makes you feel tremendously overwhelmed, don’t worry about it. Butcher paper, pencils–voila! Simple and fun, and a great way to get kids involved.
  6. No scented candles. This is an all-the-time hosting thing. Candles are lovely–the more, the better…but no scented candles to get all mixed up with the great food smells. There is nothing worse than candy-cane candle smell times stuffing smell.
  7. Don’t go overboard on hors d’oeuvres. People are serious about Thanksgiving food, and most of them are practicing some sort of complex strategy for how to consume a staggering amount of both turkey and pie. You can’t win with lots of appetizers–if you have tons, and people eat them all, then they’ll be angry with you for filling up their stomachs, stealing their pie space. But if they don’t touch them, practicing their strategy, then you’ll feel bad about all the time you spent wrapping pigs in their yummy little blankets.
  8. Spatchcock your turkey. I know. I know. It sounds illegal. But it’s a serious time-and-complexity saver. Here’s a post that explains it all, but basically, you’re cutting through the backbone so that the turkey can lay flat, allowing it to cook quickly and evenly. Jackpot! I know this doesn’t allow for the beautiful presentation of the whole bird, but I think it’s worth it, for the crispy skin and the even cooking. And all the extremely obvious jokes.
  9. Double the mashed potatoes. Trust me.
  10. Supply leftover containers. This is a serious sacrifice, I know, and there is a tendency to want to hoard all the delicious leftovers, but really: you can’t eat as many as you think, and it is such a lovely touch to have to-go containers at the ready, so that everyone can pack up the perfect leftover meal.

After finding Shauna, I am ordering her book, Bread and Wine: A love letter to life around the table with recipes. Bread & Wine is a collection of essays about family relationships, friendships, and the meals that bring us together. It is a celebration of food shared, reminding readers of the joy found in a life around the table. Sounds pretty fab to me!

Bread and Wine | The Silver Pen

What are some of your favorite Thanksgiving tips, tricks and recipes? What advice would you give to someone who’s hosting Thanksgiving, possibly for the first time?

Leave a comment


  1. Emily says

    I think her tips are very good. I would second her tips to: keep it simple, ask others to participate by bringing a dish, and don’t strive for perfection [I am a recovering perfectionist]! Now in my 60’s and having hosted many Thanksgivings, I am very relaxed and have a lot more fun
    than when it all had to be ‘just so’. About a month before Tgiving, I order flowers, plan the table setting and the menu. Then I decide what part of the meal I’ll ask others to bring. Now when people arrive for dinner, I deliberately ask them to help me with some part of dinner while we enjoy a glass of wine in the kitchen. People love to help out. Above all: you are making Thanksgiving memories – make sure they are happy ones.

  2. johnross says

    Good tips…family and friends are the best , with great conversations. Extra stuffing for me. You are very right about fewer apps.